The Most Expensive Salesperson You'll Ever Hire Is the Wrong One
Why getting recruitment wrong could be costing your business tens of thousands – and what I'm developing to help you avoid it.
Over the years, I've recruited hundreds of salespeople. Some went on to become absolute superstars, smashing targets, winning awards and making their companies a fortune. Others were about as useful in a sales meeting as a chocolate teapot. They looked fantastic on paper, interviewed beautifully, said all the right things and then, once employed, couldn't sell umbrellas in a thunderstorm.
And that's the problem with sales recruitment. Some of the best interviewees turn out to be the worst salespeople.
Think about it. Salespeople are trained to sell themselves. They know how to build rapport, ask questions, overcome objections and create a favorable impression. When they walk into an interview, they're doing exactly what they've been trained to do. They're selling. Unfortunately, what they're selling is themselves, and that doesn't necessarily mean they'll be any good at selling your products or services.
I've seen businesses make the same recruitment mistakes repeatedly, and the financial consequences can be staggering.
The Hidden Cost of Getting It Wrong
Let's imagine you recruit a salesperson on an annual salary of £50,000 or US$65,000, with commission potential, a company car, benefits and all the usual extras. You spend money advertising the position, interviewing candidates, checking references and bringing the successful applicant on board.
Then comes the training. Your sales manager spends weeks showing them the ropes. Other members of the team help them understand the products, systems and customers. Perhaps you send them on external training courses. Meanwhile, they're earning a salary but producing very little revenue.
Three months later, you're beginning to have doubts. Six months later, you're having difficult conversations about performance. Nine months later, you finally accept that you've hired the wrong person.
By now, the cost is far greater than their salary.
You've lost management time, training costs, potential sales, opportunities with customers and possibly even existing business. Your other salespeople have had to pick up the slack, and your sales manager has spent more time managing an underperformer than developing the people who could actually grow the business.
And here's the real killer. You've now got to start the entire recruitment process again.
Depending on the salary, commission structure, training investment and lost opportunities, a poor sales hire could easily cost a business tens of thousands. In some cases, particularly with senior sales executives responsible for major accounts, the financial damage could be considerably higher.
Yet many companies still recruit salespeople using little more than a CV, a couple of interviews and a reference from somebody who probably wants to get rid of them anyway.
My Four-Part Sales Recruitment Process
Having recruited hundreds of people throughout my career, I've developed a four-part process that has served me well. It's not foolproof, because people are people, but it has helped me make far better recruitment decisions.
Stage One: The Gut Feel
I know some HR professionals will disagree with me here, but my first assessment has always been gut feel.
When somebody walks into the room, I look at how they present themselves, communicate, listen and engage. Do they have energy? Are they genuinely interested in the opportunity? Do they ask intelligent questions? Can they hold a conversation without dominating it?
More importantly, do I get the feeling that this is somebody I would trust representing my business?
Now, gut feel isn't enough on its own. First impressions can be misleading, and we all have unconscious biases. That's precisely why I never allow this first stage to become the final decision. It gives me an initial impression that needs to be tested against more objective evidence.
Stage Two: The Assessment
This is where things start to get interesting.
Throughout my career, I've used various assessment tools to help me understand candidates beyond what they tell me during an interview.
I want to know what motivates them, how they communicate, how they handle rejection and whether they have the behavioral characteristics needed to succeed in a demanding sales environment.
Some people love meeting new prospects but struggle with follow-up. Others are excellent relationship builders but uncomfortable asking for the business. Some thrive on competition, while others prefer stability and structure.
There's nothing necessarily wrong with any of these characteristics, but different sales roles require different strengths.
A successful account manager isn't automatically going to become a successful new-business hunter. Equally, your best hunter may be hopeless at looking after existing customers.
The mistake is assuming that because somebody has worked in sales, they're suited to every sales position.
This second stage has become increasingly important to me, and it's one of the main reasons I'm now developing something new, which I'll explain shortly.
Stage Three: The In-Depth Interview
Once I've developed an initial impression and reviewed the assessment, I want to dig deeper.
I don't want rehearsed answers about being passionate, motivated or a team player. I've heard those answers thousands of times. I want evidence.
Tell me about the biggest sale you've ever made. How did you find the customer? What objections did you face? How did you overcome them? What did you do when the customer initially said no?
Tell me about a sale you lost. What went wrong, and what did you learn?
How do you prospect? How do you organize your day? What happens when you've made twenty calls and nobody wants to speak to you?
I also want to understand their attitude towards technology, CRM systems, LinkedIn and, increasingly, artificial intelligence. Today's salesperson needs more than a winning smile and a firm handshake.
I listen carefully, probe for specifics and look for consistency between what the candidate says, what their assessment suggests and what their previous achievements demonstrate.
The objective isn't to catch somebody out. It's to discover whether they have the skills, behaviors, motivation and resilience needed to succeed.
Stage Four: The Career Presentation
Here's something that many companies get completely wrong.
They spend the entire recruitment process expecting candidates to sell themselves, forgetting that the employer also has to sell the opportunity.
Once I've decided that somebody is the right person, the fourth stage becomes my career presentation.
I want them to understand the business, the opportunities, the earning potential, the training, the support and what their future could look like.
I want them leaving that meeting excited about joining the company, understanding what's expected and believing they have a genuine opportunity to build a successful career.
Remember, the very best candidates often have choices. Recruitment isn't simply about selecting people. It's also about attracting and retaining them.
Why I'm Developing Sales Talent IQ
After years of recruiting, training and working with salespeople across the world, one question keeps coming back to me.
What if we could identify the characteristics that make somebody successful in a particular sales role before we employ them?
Not simply whether they're outgoing or introverted, confident or reserved, but whether their behavioral tendencies, motivations, selling approach and working preferences match what the job actually requires.
That's why I'm currently developing Sales Talent IQ, a practical assessment designed specifically for sales recruitment and development.
My objective is to help CEOs, sales directors, business owners and recruitment professionals make better-informed decisions before committing substantial resources to the wrong appointment.
I also want it to help businesses understand the salespeople they already employ. Where are their natural strengths? What could be holding them back? What kind of coaching would help them improve? Are they better suited to winning new business, managing relationships or developing existing accounts?
And in today's world, we also need to consider how salespeople adapt to changing buyer behavior. Customers are researching suppliers, comparing alternatives and using artificial intelligence long before they speak to a salesperson. The ability to build trust, ask intelligent questions, listen and use technology effectively has never been more important.
The aim is to create something practical, understandable and useful, rather than another complicated report that gets filed away and never looked at again.
Imagine being able to identify potential warning signs before making an expensive recruitment decision, or recognizing strengths in an existing salesperson that have never been fully developed.
Even preventing one poor appointment could potentially save a business tens of thousands.
Of course, no assessment can guarantee success, and I wouldn't trust anybody who claimed otherwise. Sales Talent IQ is being developed as a decision-support tool, not a crystal ball or a replacement for good interviewing, reference checks and sound management judgement.
I'd Like Your Help Developing It
Here's where I'd really value your input.
Rather than developing Sales Talent IQ in isolation and then telling the world how wonderful it is, I'd like to involve the people who could actually benefit from using it.
If you're a CEO, sales director, HR professional, recruiter or business owner, I'd love to hear your thoughts.
What are the biggest problems you face when recruiting salespeople? What characteristics do you wish you could identify before employing somebody? What warning signs have you missed in the past?
Perhaps you've hired somebody who interviewed brilliantly but couldn't deliver. Or maybe you've employed somebody who didn't make a particularly strong first impression but turned out to be one of your best salespeople.
I'd also be interested in hearing what you'd like included in the assessment. Motivation? Resilience? Prospecting ability? Relationship-building skills? Coachability? Attitude towards technology? Or something completely different?
And what about the salespeople already working for you? Would you value an assessment that identifies their strengths, highlights development opportunities and helps managers decide where to focus their coaching?
Having worked with hundreds of Vistage and TEC groups over the years, I've heard countless business owners discuss the challenges of finding, developing and retaining good people. That's why I particularly want to hear from business leaders who face these decisions every day.
Your suggestions could help shape the final product.
Would You Like to Be One of My Beta Testers?
I'm looking for a select group of volunteers to participate in the free beta-testing phase of Sales Talent IQ once the assessment is ready.
The assessment is still being developed, and that's exactly why I'm inviting people to get involved now. I want potential users to help determine what should be included, what information would be most valuable and how the results should be presented.
Selected beta testers will have the opportunity to try the assessment when it becomes available, explore its findings and provide feedback on how useful it could be for recruiting, managing and developing salespeople.
There will be no charge for participating in the beta phase. In return, I'll be asking for constructive feedback on what works, what doesn't and what could be improved.
I'm particularly interested in hearing from organizations that regularly recruit salespeople, sales managers who want to understand their existing teams better, and experienced sales professionals who would like to contribute to the development process.
My ambition is to create a tool that helps businesses make smarter recruitment decisions, develop stronger sales teams and avoid some of the expensive mistakes I've witnessed throughout my career.
After all, recruiting the wrong salesperson is expensive. Recruiting the right one can transform a business.
And if we can improve the odds of getting that decision right, everybody wins.
Help Me Shape Sales Talent IQ
I'd love to hear from you, whether you have suggestions, want to share your recruitment experiences or would like to volunteer for the free beta-testing program.
I've created a short application form where you can tell me about your recruitment challenges, suggest what you'd like included in Sales Talent IQ and register your interest in participating in the beta program.
Visit https://www.productivitycentre.com/iq to share your ideas and apply for free beta testing.
And if you know a CEO, sales director, HR professional or business owner who regularly recruits salespeople, please share this article with them. Their experiences and suggestions could be invaluable.
Frank Furness CSP, GSP, FPSA
International Sales Speaker, Trainer and Author
Website: https://frankfurness.com
Email: frank@frankfurness.com
The right salesperson can make you a fortune. The wrong one can cost you one. Let's get better at telling the difference.





